Pickup only
45 Water St., Wiscasset, ME 4578
Open againin about 10 hoursonMon, 3:00PM
Valentine's Day SpecialsAppetizersOur Famous SoupSarah's SaladsFresh Dough PizzaWhaleboats & MateysBurgersOriginal SandwichesSeafoodSarah’s Sides

Our online ordering is temporarily down, please call us at (207) 882-7504 to place an order.

Sorry, our online ordering is temporarily offline, please call in your order directly at (207) 882-7504.
Made fresh daily with local seafood, fresh vegetables and choice meats
Fresh Dough Pizza
Choice of Thick or Thin Crust, White or Wheat. Gluten Free Crust available for 9" Pizzas for $2.75. Cheese is included!
Specialty Pizzas
Choice of Thick or Thin Crust, White or Wheat. Gluten Free Crust available for 9" Pizzas for $2.75. Cheese is included!
Whaleboats & Mateys
Our fresh-dough calzone on white or wheat, stuffed with mozzarella & cheddar and baked until golden brown. Whaleboats can be downsized to a Matey for $1 less
The Matey
A smaller version of Sarah's Whaleboat
Additional toppings available. Gluten free option available
Accompanied by lettuce, tomato, chips & pickle. Sarah's homemade tartar available upon request
Sarah's Cafe and Twin Schooner Pub
45 Water St., Wiscasset, ME
(207) 882-7504
© 2025 Pizzamico, LLC